State Public Sector IT Master Plan
Executive Summary
 
 

Introduction

    The State Public Sector Information Technology Master Plan (ITMP) undertakes to lay the foundation for transforming the operations of the public sector through the strategic deployment of information technology (IT). It is intended as an advisory and guiding document that charts the overall direction towards which the government can pursue in enhancing the efficiency and effectiveness of its delivery of services; while at the same time strengthening the decision making process. This is aimed at enhancing the international competitiveness of the state and improving the standards of living of the people.

    In view of the rapid advancement in information technologies, the ITMP should be treated as a dynamic document which needs to be reviewed and revised every two years, or even annually. This is particularly so with respect to the technology portion of the plan. The frequency of review and revision is very much dependent on the needs and changes that have occurred at the material time.
 

Vision and Objectives

    In line with the vision of the Sabah IT Council, the strategic vision of the ITMP is to achieve administrative renewal and bring the state closer to its citizens through a fully electronic government by the year 2002. As such, the mission of the ITMP is to facilitate the reinvention of the government through strategic deployment of information and multimedia technologies. In this respect, the objectives of the ITMP can be expressed as, among others:

Terms of Reference

    The terms of reference of the ITMP are:

     These terms of reference are addressed within the two volumes of the ITMP, viz.:
 
                    Volume 1: Main Report
                            Chapter 1: Introduction
                            Chapter 2: Environmental Scanning
                            Chapter 3: Issues, Risks and Scenarios
                            Chapter 4: Recommendations
                            Chapter 5: Action Plan
                            Chapter 6: Summary of IT Service Delivery Recommendations

                    Volume 2: Technical Report
                            Chapter 1: Evolution of Information Technologies
                            Chapter 2: Sabah ITMP Models
                            Chapter 3: Infrastructural Services
                            Chapter 4: Computing and Storage Technologies
                            Chapter 5: Service Access
                            Chapter 6: Security
                            Chapter 7: Future Directions
                            Chapter 8: IT Management
                            Chapter 9: Performance Measurement
                            Chapter 10: Technology Acquisition
                            Chapter 11: Proposed Systems and Applications
                            Chapter 12: Implementation Strategy
 

    Volume 1 analyses the current status of IT resources in the public sector in an effort to determine the strengths and weaknesses present. The external environment is also scanned to identify opportunities and threats to the state, and in particular to the successful implementation of the ITMP. These exercises have provided the background to the formulation of the various strategies and actions necessary to transform the operations of the public sector.

    Volume 2 discusses the various available and emerging technologies, and the infrastructure model that would be useful for the implementation of the ITMP. It also identifies the technologies and structures needed to create an electronic government.
 

Environmental Scanning

    In this era, knowledge is the key to the success of a country, organisation or individual. Countries that possess the capabilities to generate and apply knowledge has a better than average chance to prosper. The key enabling tool for this scenario is affordable and readily available information technologies.

    Advancements in technology, communications and transportation have created the borderless world, where almost anything can be made anywhere and sold anywhere else. This has resulted in the globalisation of the world economy. A scenario that has created both opportunities and threats to developed and developing countries alike. As a result, change has become the norm, the only constant. Tapscott and Caston [1993:1] best describe the rapid pace of change occurring around the world:

It happens to you at various points throughout the day - starting with reading the morning newspaper and ending with watching the late night news. The staggering changes taking place in the world and their implications for our professional and personal lives are relentless, many unimagined just a few years, months, or even weeks ago. There is a new openness and volatility that seem rich with opportunity and fraught with danger for humanity, your country, your organization, and you.     In spite of these changes, countries can deploy technologies strategically to tap into the opportunities and neutralise the threats present. In fact, developing countries can leapfrog into the information age as they are not encumbered by legacy systems commonly found in developed countries. Malaysia is a typical example, where a national effort is geared towards developing the Multimedia Super Corridor (MSC). The success of the MSC will undoubtedly propel Malaysia into a world "power" to be reckoned with. As such, the MSC presents great opportunities for Sabah to tap upon.

    Information technology is likely to drastically change the way we live, work and play. As the people embrace the new technologies, their expectations of the government will change accordingly. This change in expectation will place a greater burden on the government to efficiently and effectively deliver its services. Table E1 summarises the major opportunities and threats to the state after scanning the environment.

    The government structure, as it stands today, was created in an effort to manage the industrial era. This structure is considered obsolete in today?s environment, as it does not provide the capability to respond quickly to changing needs of the society, the economy and the people. It is liken to a super tanker navigating through a winding river - slow and cautious. Nevertheless, the strategic deployment of appropriate technologies provides the opportunity to reinvent the government. This will result in drastically improved service delivery, facilitating the creation of an internationally competitive economy. Information technology has been identified as the key strategic enabling tool for the whole exercise. Before proceeding further, a review of the current IT capacities of the government was conducted, and the result is summarised in Table E2.

 
 
 
TABLE E1. Summary of Environmental Scan
 
Domain
Past (1990-1996)
Future (1997-2002)
Major Opportunities
Major Threats
Economy
  • Nation as primary locus of economic development
  • Cities as satellites of national capitals
  • Network as emerging locus of economic development
  • Cities as nodes on global networks
  • Globalisation: Local content, world market
  • Attract overseas investment and skills
  • That globalisation bypasses Sabah
  • Strong internal conflict among ASEAN members 
Technology
  • Separate computing, telecommunications, content industries
  • Convergence and emerging new IT industry structure
  • Technology transfer
  • Local value-added in the form of content
  • Inability to absorb new technologies
  • Disintermediation
Society
  • Local communities isolated from commercial capitals
  • Supercities linked to local communities through networks
  • Bringing government closer to citizens
  • IT to capture and preserve culture
  • Lack of attention to needs of periphery
  • Rise of xenophobic nationalism
Law
  • Immature legal infrastructure for emerging trend to electronic commerce 
  • No infrastructure to enable electronic government
  • National cyberlaw to enable E-commerce and government
  • International services trade accord in WTO
  • Regional accords on e-commerce
  • Local legislation aligned with global and national trends
  • E-government aligned with e-commerce law
  • Government process re-engineering
  • Conflicting local, national, regional, and international 

  • e-commerce laws 
  • Traditional public tendering practices continue in force
Regional
  • ASEAN trade policy focused on capitals
  • Growth triangles to support industry
  • Commodity inputs
  • New electronic infrastructure to support emerging growth regions
  • Differentiated inputs
  • Links to Singapore, Philippines, and Indonesia
  • Borneo.net as shared digital infrastructure
  • Failure to assist weaker regions to develop industries
  • New leadership with competing agendas
 
 
 
 
 
Table E2. Summary of Existing IT Resources in Public Sector
 
Telecommunications
  • WAN links mostly 9.6 kbps lease or x.25 base
  • lack of telephone lines to remote locations
  • lack of high speed lines between state government agencies
  • no broadband network present
  • no usage of public voicemail and faxback services
Networks
  • mostly Ethernet (10BaseT, 10Base2)
  • protocols used TCP/IP, NetBEUI, IPX, Decnet, Banyan
Computers
  • PC Servers, Apple Mac
  • Sun, Intergraph, Wang, AS/400, VAX, DEC Alpha, HP
Operating Systems
  • MS-DOS, Windows, Windows for Workgroup, Windows 95, Windows NT
  • Banyan, SCO, UNIX, HP-UX, Sun Solaris, VMS, AOS/VS II, AEGIS 
Databases
  • Variety of PC based and proprietary server based databases scattered
  • Foxpro, dBase III/IV, Framework III
  • Borland, Informix, Exsys, Oracle, MS Access
Word Processors
  • MS Word, Wordstar, Multimate
Spreadsheets
  • Excel, Lotus 123, Quattro Pro, CEO
Interfaces
  1. MS-Windows dominates, Internet Explorer in a couple of locations
  2. A number of PCs are too old to run GUIs
 
    There are currently 219 IT-related posts in the government proper (i.e., excluding the statutory bodies). Of this, 49.3 percent are in the professional category, while the balance are support and data entry operators. As a result of heavy workload, relatively lower pay and lack of advancement opportunities, the turnover rate of IT professionals in the public sector is fairly high.

    The Human Resource Development Bureau is the key organisation responsible for training government officers. Computer training is among the many courses that the HRBD offers. In view of the lack of qualified trainers and appropriate facilities, the HRDB only conducts 10 computer training courses a year. The maximum capacity it can cater is about 800 if the course is conducted back-to-back throughout the year.

    The IT literacy rate of the more senior officers are relatively lower as compared to their junior counterparts. This is so because the junior officers are of the younger generations, most of whom have already been exposed to IT during their studies.

    For ease of reference, Table E3 summarises the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats with respect to the state of IT in Sabah.

 
 
 
Table E3. Summary of SWOT
 
STRENGTHS
WEAKNESSES
OPPORTUNITIES
THREATS
  • strong leadership support
  • rich natural resource content (in the form of data and information)
  • key "centres of competence"
  • a lack of clear-cut policy direction
  • time-consuming procurement procedures
  • weak financial position as a result of depleting resources
  • inadequate telecommunications network infrastructure
  • weak information technology architecture 
  • a lack of data administration
  • scarcity of skilled manpower resources
  • data and knowledge sharing
  • co-ordinated agency efforts
  • motivated workforce
  • well-informed public
  • responsive, high-quality services
  • successful local firms
  • willing overseas investors
  • lack of sound technology management capability
  • poor security measures
  • rapid change in world scenario
  • advancements of neighbouring countries and states
  •  
     

    Critical Gaps

        The critical gaps as identified can be categorised into three major domains - policy, technology and human resource. Table E4 summarises these gaps with their respective domains.
     
     

    Possible Risk Factors

        Organisations often abandon IT projects that fail to accomplish their intended objectives, or because those objectives change before the project goes online. Government agencies often appear to have even more trouble than the private sector in successfully applying new technology. This is because the policy choices and management processes that are inherent in government create special challenges for IT managers, and add several risks that are unique to the public sector. These common hazards, only a few of which are technical in nature, act as barriers to the success of IT innovation and present a serious challenge to public managers who are responsible for choosing, funding, and building new systems. These hazards are summarised as shown in Table E5.

     
     
     
    Table E4. Summary of Critical Gaps
     
    Domain
    Gaps
    Policy
    • lack of a state-wide IT deployment and management plan
    • lack of information sharing policies
    • lack of clear-cut policy on IT-related human resource development and training
    • information is not managed as a state-wide strategic resource
    • existing laws, regulations and policies that are not conducive to the implementation of the electronic government initiative
    Technology
    • no integrated and managed state-wide network infrastructure
    • technology deployment emphasised on automating existing processes
    • varying computing standards between and among ministries, departments and agencies
    Human resource
    • insufficient IT professionals trained with current technological know-how
    • lack of information management skills
    • critical shortage of qualified trainers/instructors to train end-users
    • communities may not be ready, both technically and mentally
     

     
     

    Table E5. Summary of Potential Risk Factors
     
    Policy Environment
    Organisation
    Business Processes
    Technology
    • government?s business is public 
    • divided and proscribed authority
    • complex programme linkages
    • multiple stakeholders with competing goals
    • highly regulated procurement
    • short-term budgets, long-term projects
  • poor alignment between IT objectives and agency goals
  • poor management support within the organisation
  • inadequate resource allocations to IT deployment
  • inability to align with vendors who will support deployment
  • wrong resource mix
  • altered business process may not meet current needs
  • lack of consensus needed to formulate radical new design
  • overlooking the initial process redesign step
  • sub-optimisation to local level, with poor linkages to external agencies
  • failure to understand the IT performance envelope
  • selection of technology which cannot deliver the functionality needed
  • selection of technology which will become obsolete before the benefits can be obtained
  •  
     
     

    Recommendations

        The recommended strategies and their respective actions are formulated to breach the critical gaps in reaching the targets set forth in the ITMP. These strategies and actions are summarised in Table E6. It should be noted that the numbers corresponding to the actions do not denote the priorities of the said action. they are meant for ease of reference only. The prioritised actions are presented in Figure E1.

     
     
     
    Table E6. Summary of Strategies and Actions
     
    Strategies
    Actions
    Balance Investments in Technology, Organisation and Resources
    • Administrative renewal
    • Networked delivery of information services
    • Government policy initiatives
    • Government-citizen communications
    • Government-enterprise co-operation via EDI
    • Interagency co-ordination
    • Digital delivery of government services
    Utilise Sabah.net as the Basis for Strategic Alliances
    • State government as a strong centre
    • State initiatives closely couple to the MSC
    • Co-operative links to growth areas in the region
    • Direct links to key cities and industries in ASEAN
    • Strategic alliances with technology providers
    Invest in Manpower: Both Technical and Managerial
    • Co-ordinate top-down education with bottom-up training
    • Executive education focused on information management
    • Technical training from leading international sources
    • Technology management development
    • End user training to empower content creation and use
    Leverage Available Resources: Public and Private
    • Internal resources throughout state government
    • Local technology vendors
    • Overseas sources of advanced technologies
    • National and international telecommunications operators
    • Regional universities and commercial schools
    • Service industries as sources of content
    • The MSC as a source of technology adapted to local needs
    Deploy Broad Range of IT-based Solutions and Adapt Processes
    • Mainframe technology for institutional systems
    • Multi-tier client-server architecture as computing standard
    • Open Internet technology as the network standard
    • Advanced facsimile technology for document distribution
    • Voice (voicemail, etc.) integrated with digital networks
    • Wireless (mobile, paging, GPS, LEO) as emerging standard
    • Platform-independent languages for applications
    Structure Supply-Demand Relationships over Time
    • Data hubs and warehouses
    • Develop strategic IT competence centres
    • Empower monitoring and co-ordination
    • Establish and use performance indicators
     
     
     
     
    Figure E1. Prioritised Strategic Actions
     
     
     

    Action Plan

        There are four main stages to the deployment of ITMP. Each stage provides immediate value and prepares the way for the following stage (see Figure E2). Table E7 summarises the areas of focus, actors and technology needed to complete the various stages of implementation. Table E8 identifies the technology-user pairs for actions, and Table E9 determines the roles and responsibilities of the key actors.
     
     

    Implementation Machinery

        As the client to the ITMP and the secretariat to the Sabah IT Council, the Science and Technology Unit (STU) should be designated and empowered as the chief initiating and implementing agent of the plan. The STU shall carry out these responsibilities in close consultation with the Working Committee on IT Deployment in the Public Sector of the Sabah IT Council. (The same Committee also serves as the Steering Committee to the ITMP.) Special task forces comprising technical personnel from relevant parties shall be formed under the purview of the Working Committee to tackle technical issues that may arise. Examples of such task forces may include, among others, IT utilisation policy, IT training, network administration policy, process reinvention, IT standards, etc. Figure E3 depicts the machinery necessary to implement the ITMP successfully.

     

     
    Figure E2: Stages in ITMP Deployment
     
    STAGE 
    I
    STAGE 
    II
    STAGE 
    III
    STAGE
    IV
    Fully Electronic State Government
    Direct Service Delivery @ Sabah.net
    Intranet/Web
    Transactions
    Integration with State Operational Databases
    Dynamic Web Pages
    Information Search
    Static Web Pages
    E-mail, FOD, etc.
    Complexity >>
     
     
     
     
    TABLE E7. Summary of Focus, Actors and Technology
     
    Stage I
    Focus Significant Milestones
    Key Actor
    Key Technology
    External
    Awareness Launch of Sabah.net
    CMD
    Intra/Internet
    Connectivity Email/fax access to all state service
    KKIPC
    Intranet
    Access Catalogue of public information 
    SSL
    Internet
    Access Search engine to deliver public data
    SSL
    Internet
    Internal
    Connectivity State-wide Email links among most offices
    KKIPC
    Intranet
    Connectivity Voicemail/pager access to mobile workers
    KKIPC
    Voice network
    Information Distribution Standards for electronic distribution of circulars, reports, forms, procedures, and other internal documents 
    SCSD
    PDF, FOD
    Information Access Standards for electronic publishing and access to all public information
    SSL/STU
    PDF, FOD
    Stage II
    External
    Access Public access to GIS information
    SCSD
    Data security
    Community State-wide job opportunities online
    SSL/CMD
    Intranet
    Industry Sustainable tourism prototype
    STPC
    Intranet
    Community Electronic communities pilot project
    SSL
    Internet
    Renewal Electronic tendering prototype
    KKIPC/SCSD
    E-commerce
    Internal
    Connectivity State-wide Email links among all offices
    KKIPC
    Intranet
    Learning Distance training prototype- IT workers
    SCSD
    emergent
    Renewal State-wide data administration initiative
    SCSD
     
    Renewal Online extracts of public information
    SCSD
    RDBMS
    Connectivity State-wide network management
    KKIPC
     
    Connectivity Information and network architecture
    KKIPC
    emergent
    Stage III
    External
    Community Lifelong learning prototype  
    emergent
    Industry Online international investment forum
    KKIPC
    Internet
    Community Digital library field trials
    SSL
    emergent
    Internal
    Connectivity Multimedia links among key offices
    KKIPC
    Intranet
    Integration Data warehousing for all shared data
    SCSD
    Objects
    Integration State-wide voice and data network 
    KKIPC
    ATM
    Connectivity GPS tracking of mobile resources
    KKIPC
    GPS
    Integration Information resource management policy
    CMD/STU
     
    Stage IV
    External
      All Strategic ITMP initiatives underway:    
     
    • Sustainable tourism management
    CIO
     
     
    • Digital libraries
    CIO
     
     
    • Electronic communities
    CIO
     
     
    • Lifelong learning
    CIO
     
    • Electronic commerce
    CIO
     
    Int.
    Connectivity Multimedia links among state offices
    KKIPC
    Intranet
    Connectivity Broadband networks where necessary
    KKIPC
    ATM
     
     
     
     
     
    TABLE E8. Technology-User Pairs
     
    Mission Core Technologies End Users
    Actor
    Management Information Systems
    • Systems Development Life Cycle
    • Database Management
    • Data Centre Operations
    Internal Business Processes 

    Management Reporting 

    Decision Support Systems

    SCSD
    Shared Systems 
    • Basic Data Administration
    • Multi-user Database Management
    • Systems Integration
    Cross-Ministry Processes 

    Information Dissemination 

    Decision Support Systems

    SCSD
    Data Warehousing
    • Advanced Data Administration
    • Data Extracting and Mining
    Decision Support Systems 

    Information Dissemination

    SCSD
    Transaction Processing
    • Internal Network Management (POS)
    • Remote support for terminals
    Internal Business Processes 

    Cross-Ministry Processes

    KKIP-C
    Electronic Commerce
    • Network Management (Public)
    • Online Data Security
    • Electronic Payment Mechanisms
    • Extranet (TCP/IP, HTML, etc.)
    External Business Processes 

    Commercial Suppliers 

    General Public

    KKIP-C
    Integrated Voice/Data Services
    • Network Management (digital PBX)
    • Speech Recognition and Synthesis
    • Mobile Communications
    Internal telephone users 

    Field Workers 

    General Public

    KKIP-C
    Online Publishing
    • TCP/IP network management Multimedia, HTML, Intranet
    • Information Management
    General Public (Public Information, Forms, Reports, Queries)
    SSL
    Electronic Communities
    • Internet, Bulletin Boards
    General Public Special Interest Groups
    SSL
    Information Dissemination
    • HTML, PDF, Internet
    • Fax-on-Demand, digital pagers, etc.
    General Public (Forms, Reports, Queries)
    SSL
     
     
     
     
     
    Table E9. Responsibility Allocation
     
    UNIT
    SITC/STU
    SCSD
    SSL
    KKIPC
    Domain
    Policy and Co-ordination
    Institutional Systems
    Distribution and Publication
    Network
    Operations
    STRATEGIC        
    IT Masterplanning
    Lead
    Support
    Support
    Support
    IT Resource Planning and Control
    Integrate
    Support
    Support
    Support
    IT Administration Planning and Control
    Integrate
    Support
    Support
    Support
    Project Management and Change Control
    Monitor
    Primary
    Primary
    Primary
    Service Level Control
    Monitor
    Primary
    Primary
    Primary
    Design, Development and Maintenance
    Co-ordinate
    Primary
    Primary
    Primary
    Administration
    Policy
    Data Services
    Public Access
    Network Services
    Production
    Monitor
    Primary
    Primary
    Primary
    Distribution
    Monitor
    Primary
    Primary
    Primary
    Information Use and User Satisfaction
    Monitor
    Survey
    Survey
    Survey
     
     
     
    Figure E3. Machinery to Implement the ITMP
     
     

     
    Role of STU

        As the lead actor, the STU is the focal point in implementing the ITMP. Specifically, the STU shall: